Perhaps tragedies are only tragedies in the presence
of love, which confers meaning to loss. Loss is not
felt in the absence of love. “The queen died and then
the king died” is a plot, wrote E. M. Forster in The Art
of the Novel, but “the queen died and then the king died
of grief” is a story.
The Light of the World
Elizabeth Alexander
I suppose it was over long before I knew
and maybe that was because I loved you and hoped.
You know, it was the kind and sort of love that grew
in the same plot of earth and at about the same
time, it felt the same sun and rain and snow though
maybe not the same amounts and maybe not
at the same time. You had been rooted
a few months before me and bore
the empty crib by yourself longer and more loudly.
Our mother used to say you cried for the first
eighteen months of your life so that means
I heard you for only a small few of those months and by
then with the three of us, two and a half years old
and younger, she’d had it to her elbows—
bones
bones
she’d lean on out on the doorstep she said, away
from us long enough to not murder us. She said
this euphemistically, though over time I didn’t entirely
doubt her and it wasn’t body she’d’ve killed anyway
but she certainly in her own crave and poverty
stole from each of us bits of soul that would, like a buried
bobble dug up with a spoon and absently discarded,
prey it to her lips and keep it between her teeth. We
didn’t know what we’d dug up or what we’d lost.
Maybe it was this: in the chaos and the lull between the next
chaos it was the sound of someone’s loving
breath against our cheek. It makes me think of Alexander
Graham Bell “speaking” to his deaf mother, how he’d
rest his lips against her cheek and she, fingertips like
a thrush’s wings, would feel his words and touch her
response to him—I bet this was the kind
of contact we ached for and ultimately wouldn’t sooth
you, full to the hood with colic and trauma of her
abandonment. I think we say out of our own ache:
we say: this is what I want, we say: this is what my day needs
to look like to make me happy only I can’t reach—or
don’t want to, like the day after the blizzard, the top
of the snow goes colder, goes frozen and we stay
behind the dark window looking at the warm houses
in the valley and watch the smoke go up into the clean
sky and say I could have that but I can’t
find my coat or hat or a convenient pair of skis or skates
because see the way is paved in ice. Come spring
and given the life of seeds some of what and who
we are could make it that little bit of the way if it weren’t
for the settlement of birds, the variety of spiders,
the cinema of buds all different manner of distractions.
Rooted as we are in it we can’t know if we wintered
well at all, if we kept close enough to our heartwood
to prevent freezing altogether. I think maybe
and ultimately the great distance will never be even
or broached between us and it’s not I’ve given up
trying more it’s like the day our mother died and you’d
left hours before and I stayed and after she was
finished one of the first things I realized was she wasn’t
alive to hurt anyone ever again and maybe you should’ve
stayed to come to know that too and known
where you draw the line, when to begin to say:
I’m on my way to being through with being hurt
by you and that starts it always starts with putting it
all down and opening the window or looking up
into the sky after the Christmas blizzard is through
and seeing not just blue, no not just blue but winter
birds coming home to roost in our bare, ice crusted
birch.